The Department of Justice Canada works to reduce family violence in Canada. Learn more...
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Principles governing access awards
|
Children's best interests
|
| Provisions for dealing with cases involving child abuse and violence and spousal abuse and violence
|
|
| Penalties for unwarranted access denial
|
|
| Role of the child's wishes in access disputes
|
|
| Penalties for unwarranted breach of access or failure to exercise access |
As above. |
| Mandatory supports for separating or divorcing parents
|
1. Counselling (conciliation) meeting is a prerequisite for a parenting order (custody and access award), except when the order is interim, the need for an order is urgent, or the order is consensual. 47 percent of Family Court counselling clients are mandatory. |
| Voluntary supports for separating or divorcing parents |
|
| Mandatory supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
1. Counselling. Court-ordered counselling (conciliation). |
| Legal Aid and other legal supports for parties in access disputes, including children
|
Unknown. However there is concern that recent cutbacks to Legal Aid are making it more difficult for access and residence parents to bring enforcement applications, and for parents to defend themselves against enforcement applications. |
| Voluntary supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
|
| Mandatory supports for enforcement for access orders
|
1. Supervised access can be ordered by the courts (more likely to be ordered as a condition of interim access). Centres exist around the country, although demand exceeds supply. Program expansion is under way. |
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Principles governing access awards
|
|
| Provisions governing frequency, duration and type of access awarded
|
|
| Provisions for dealing with cases involving child abuse and violence and spousal abuse and violence
|
|
| Role of the child's wishes in access disputes
|
|
| Penalties for unwarranted access denial
|
|
| Penalties for unwarranted breach of access or failure to exercise access |
As above in counties where the custodial parent may file applications for breach of access (i.e., failure to return the child on time). |
| Mandatory supports for separating or divorcing parents
|
1. Conciliation. Provided by Friend of the Court offices in some counties in cases in which disputes have not responded to mediation. When conciliation is unsuccessful, the FOC prepares a recommendation and the court may make an order based on the recommendation. |
| Voluntary supports for separating or divorcing parents
|
|
| Mandatory supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
1. Meeting with the FOC once the FOC has determined that the parenting order has been violated. |
| Legal Aid and other legal supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
Unknown. |
| Voluntary supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
1. Mediation. Provided by the Friend of the Court. The FOC may refer the parties to mediation, with their consent, after it has found that the parenting order has been violated. |
| Mandatory supports for enforcement for access
|
Some supervised access available. Where not available, judge may order access under the supervision of a relative, or child exchange at public places such as the police station. |
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
Principles governing access awards
Divorce Act (R.S.C. 1985) |
Children's best interests
|
Penalties for denial or breach of access or failure to exercise access |
Provincial responsibility. |
Mandatory and voluntary supports for separating and divorcing parents
Divorce Act (R.S.C. 1985)
|
|
British Columbia enforces access by providing penalties against parents who "interfere with" the execution of court custody and access awards. Its Offences Act provides for fines and up to six months' imprisonment for denial of access, but does not extend to breach of access or failure to exercise access.
Access parents who wish to file interference applications must present themselves to province-run counselling and referral registries, where these exist, before proceeding with the application. As part of their rulings, judges can order mediation, parenting education, counselling or supervised access, where these services exist, although the legislation makes no specific provision for this. In very serious cases, the judge can ask the Attorney General to appoint a family advocate to represent the child's interests in court, and children's wishes are specified as a consideration in determining initial access awards. Parents involved in access enforcement disputes may use the services of family justice centres for counselling or filling out interference applications.
The province's efforts in access enforcement focus on mandatory and voluntary preventative services that may resolve disputes before they reach the court. The province operates mandatory parent education and counselling programs for separating parents making application to Provincial Court. However, these programs are not available province-wide and are voluntary where no province-run centres exist.
Parents may be denied access when the child is known to be at serious risk of abuse, and violence against a parent may be construed as part of the considerations that determine the best interests of the child. Abused spouses may apply to vary orders, and judges can order supervised access where services are available, though there is no explicit legislative authorization for this.
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
Principles governing access awards
Family Relations Act (R.S.B.C. 1979) |
Children's best interests
|
Provisions for dealing with cases involving child abuse and violence and spousal abuse and violence
|
|
Role of the child's wishes in access disputes |
|
Penalties for unwarranted access denial Family Relations Act (R.S.B.C. 1979) |
|
Penalties for unwarranted breach of access or failure to exercise access |
None. |
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
Mandatory supports for separating or divorcing parents
|
|
Voluntary supports for separating or divorcing parents
|
|
Mandatory supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
Family Justice Registries. |
Legal Aid and other legal supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
Family Legal Services provides legal services for initial custody and access orders, and variations to those orders when the client or client's children are at risk. |
Voluntary supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
Family Justice Centres. |
Mandatory supports for enforcement for access |
Courts may order supervised access (not provided as penalty) where available. Services are restricted to a handful of sites, part of an original pilot project, and privately provided under purchase of service. An evaluation was completed in 1995. |
Alberta's Family Law Statutes Amendment Act 1999 introduces provisions for access enforcement to that province. Prior to 1999, civil contempt was the only remedy available at the Superior Court level for access parents who had been wrongly denied access, and penalties for contempt included fines and up to two years' imprisonment when fines were not paid (plus other minor penalties). When the access order was granted by the lower court (Provincial Court), any person who contravened the order was liable to be held guilty of an offence, and subject to a fine or imprisonment, or both. These remedies continue to exist in addition to the new legislation. Under the new law, penalties range from compensatory access to 90 days' imprisonment. The penalties apply to custodial parents who deny access without excuse and access parents who breach access by failing to return the child without excuse. When the access denial is found to be excusable by the courts, judges may still order penalties other than fines or imprisonment.
The new law continues Superior Court jurisdiction and gives a new jurisdiction to the lower court over access enforcement. Either court has jurisdiction to enforce an access order from either level of court. When a variation of a Superior Court order is involved, however, the application must go to the Superior Court. Except for variations, the new law allows most parties to self-litigate enforcement claims through the lower court.
There are no mandatory services for parents involved in access disputes prior to the court hearing. However, access parents who have failed to attend the mandatory parenting education course at divorce will not have their enforcement applications heard.
Judges may order counselling, education or mediation as penalties for a wrongful or an excusable access denial. However, there are no provisions for judges to order supervised access and no provincially sponsored system exists. There are no provisions in the legislation for children's counsel or advocates to represent children's interests in the court disputes, and children's interests are not articulated as a consideration in determining the child's best interests.
Following a recent pilot project, parenting education courses for divorcing parents are now mandatory province-wide when an action for access is brought in the superior court. The course is not mandatory in the lower court; however, the court may order attendance as a term of relief. Attend a course is a prerequisite to all divorce applications. There is no requirement to take the course when the children are all 16 years of age and older, or when both parties certify in writing that they have entered into a written agreement settling all the issues. Parents can also be exempted from these full-day courses (two half-days) for one month when the child has been abducted, there is a unilateral change in custody, or an interim custody order has been ordered and a restraining order made against one parent.
Voluntary information services are provided by courts for divorcing and separating couples. The government Family Mediation Services program also provides mediation services, whether court-ordered or voluntary, free of charge to divorcing and separating couples when one parent's income is below $40,000, and at least one child is younger than 18 years of age. About 765 mediation files are opened yearly. Another service includes open assessments that contain recommendations regarding access, and may be subsidized when mediation is deemed inappropriate or unworkable. This service is only available for actions initiated in the Superior Court. In the lower court, when an access dispute has been adjourned to trial, a court may order an assessment, which will be prepared by Family Court counsellor's at no cost to the parties through the Custody and Access Investigations program. As well, the skill-based Communication in Conflict three-part group workshop is available to assist parents going through separation or divorce. The workshop is voluntary and accessible to anyone who contacts the Mediation Program.
Parents may be denied access when the child is known to be at serious risk of abuse. However, violence against a spouse is not specified as a consideration for judges in determining access awards based on the child's best interests. Custodial parents at risk of spousal violence may apply to vary the original access awards, and these applications may be heard at the same time as the access enforcement application.
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
Principles governing access awards Domestic Relations Act (R.S.A. 1980) Provincial Court Act(R.S.A. 1980) |
Children's best interests
Court must consider best interests of child. |
Provisions for dealing with cases involving child abuse and violence and spousal abuse and violence |
|
Role of the child's wishes in access disputes |
No provisions. |
Penalties for unwarranted access denial Family Law Statutes Act Amendments 1999 |
|
Penalties for failure to exercise access |
1. Reimbursement of expenses incurred. |
Mandatory supports for separating or divorcing parents
|
1. Parent education. Parenting after separation program. Province-wide program for all divorcing parents, teaching how divorce affects children, how divorced couples can work together to protect their interests and their children's. |
Voluntary supports for separating or divorcing parents |
|
Mandatory supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
1. Judge may order parties to attend an education seminar, counselling or mediation as a penalty for access denial or breach of access |
Legal Aid and other legal supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
1. Available for parties who cannot afford to hire their own lawyers. In 1997, 2,091 divorce cases involving child custody or access received aid. |
Voluntary supports for parents in access disputes, including children |
1. Parent education. Parenting after separation seminar. |
Mandatory supports for enforcement of access |
No provincially sponsored service available. |
Saskatchewan enforces access through a variety of penalties, ranging from compensatory access to the fines and imprisonment of civil contempt. Similar penalties apply to custodial parents who deny access and to access parents who breach access orders by failing to return the child or to exercise specified access. There is no information on how often cases enter the court, the conviction rate or the distribution of penalties. However anecdotal evidence is that the penalties are infrequently used, and the serious penalties rarely applied. Compensatory access may be the most frequently used penalty.
There are no mandatory services or programs for parents making access enforcement applications. Voluntary mediation had been available in Superior Court, but was terminated April 1, 2000 when Family Courts in the province unified. Courts may order parents to mediation as a penalty for unwarranted access denial, where it is available. Courts may also order access under supervision as a penalty.
Voluntary parenting education is available to separating and divorcing parents around the province. There are no mandatory services or programs for separating and divorcing parents.
Parents may be denied access when the child is known to be at serious risk of abuse. Child protection laws link spousal violence with child abuse in assessing risk to the child, so that spousal violence figures in determining the child's best interests when child abuse is present. There are supervised access centres in Saskatoon and Regina.
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
Principles governing access awards Children's Law Act (S.S. 1990) |
Children's best interests
|
Provisions for dealing with cases involving child abuse and violence and spousal abuse and violence |
|
Role of the child's wishes in access disputes |
1. Child's wishes considered in determination of child's best interests. |
Penalties for denial of specified access Children's Law Act (S.S. 1990) |
|
Penalties for unwarranted breach of access or failure to exercise access
|
|
Mandatory supports for separating or divorcing parents |
|
Voluntary supports for separating or divorcing parents |
|
Mandatory supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
|
Legal Aid and other legal supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
Legal Aid available to parties in disputes in which parties are on social assistance, or when costs of a lawyer would reduce their financial resources to social assistance levels. |
Voluntary supports for parents in access disputes |
|
Mandatory supports for enforcement of access |
|
In Manitoba, access is enforced through several laws, including provisions for mediation in The Court of Queen's Bench Act, and penalties ranging from fines to imprisonment for civil contempt. Access enforcement applies to custodial parents who deny access without excuse, as well as to access parents who breach access by failing to return the child on time.
There are no mandatory programs or services prior to the court hearing for parents bringing access enforcement applications. However, once the case reaches court, judges may refer people to mediation. The courts may order supervised access as one of the remedies for breach of access or access denial. However, although some government-supported supervised access centres exist, there is no province-wide system. The courts' ability to order supervised access depends on availability of service.
Voluntary mediation and parent education is available without cost to parties involved in access disputes, and for divorcing and separating parents. The province also offers voluntary programs for children of divorcing or separating parents and parents in dispute.
Whether access is in the child's best interests determines whether access is granted. Parents may be denied access when the child is known to be at serious risk of abuse, and violence against a parent may be a consideration in awarding and adjudicating access disputes. The abused spouse can seek a wide range of protective relief (e.g. restraining order) and make a request to vary the access order. The court may require access supervision.
Manitoba's approach to access enforcement and to other family law issues focusses on dispute resolution alternatives to litigation, and it is increasingly looking to mediation. The Manitoba Civil Justice Review Task Force (1996) endorsed an alternative dispute resolution approach, and recommended a system of mandatory screening for mediation for all separating parents, and expansion of the mandate of existing government-sponsored, court-connected mediation services to provide comprehensive mediation services for access, custody, support and property issues. A comprehensive mediation pilot project is under way (see Chapter 3, section 3.2 for a preliminary evaluation).
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
Principles governing access awards The Family Maintenance Act (R.S.M. 1987) |
Children's best interests
|
Provisions for dealing with cases involving child abuse and violence and spousal abuse and violence
|
|
Role of the child's wishes in access disputes |
1. Wishes of the child are a consideration in determining the best interests of the child. |
Penalties for unwarranted access denial Child Custody Enforcement Act (R.S.M. 1987; contempt clauses) Family Maintenance Act (R.S.M. 1987) |
|
Penalties for unwarranted breach of access or failure to exercise access |
|
Mandatory supports for separating or divorcing families
|
1. Parenting education. For the Sake of the Children program (see below) is a pre-requisite for parents wanting to participate in the province-wide voluntary mediation program. It is not mandatory otherwise. |
Voluntary supports for separating or divorcing families |
|
Mandatory supports for parties in access disputes, including children.
|
1. Parent Education. For the Sake of the Children is a pre-requisite for parties wanting to mediate access disputes through Family Conciliation (see above). It is not mandatory otherwise. |
Legal Aid and other legal supports for parties in access disputes, including children
|
|
Voluntary supports for parties in access disputes, including children |
|
Mandatory supports for access enforcement
|
1. Courts may order supervised access. However, government-funded supervised access services are available in Winnipeg and a few regional centres, on a fee-for-service or means-tested basis. |