Appendix I:
Jurisdictional Breakdown of Activities (Part 2)
Ontario
Ministry of the Attorney General (MAG)
- The Family Law Rules are specialized rules of
procedure for family law cases. Since 1999, they have
applied to family law cases in the Family Court of the Superior Court of
Justice (“Unified Family Court”) and the Ontario Court of Justice. Effective
July 1, 2004, the application of the Rules was expanded to the
Superior Court of Justice, resulting in a single set of court rules for all
family trial courts. The Rules emphasize the early resolution of cases
and incorporate a system of case management, a key feature of which includes a
duty to manage cases expeditiously and fairly.
- Family Law Information Centres (FLICs) have now
been established at all court locations across Ontario. FLICs provide valuable family law information to members of the public, whether or
not they have started a court case.
- The Mandatory Information Program at the Superior
Court of Justice in Toronto is required by all litigants in contested family
law proceedings before continuing with their court
proceeding. Litigants are presented with information about the process of
separation and divorce, options for dispute resolution, legal procedures and
support available in the community.
- All family litigants in the Ontario Court of Justice in Toronto have access to information sessions as a result of the Donner
Pilot Project. Evening information sessions are provided to clients and
cover a wide range of issues related to family law, the court process and the
impact of divorce and separation on children.
- The Dispute Resolution Officer is also connected to
the Superior Court of Justice in Toronto. Senior
family law lawyers meet with parties prior to court appearances and attempts to
resolve the matters through negotiation and resolve the matter before it comes
before a judge.
- To facilitate public awareness and understanding of the Child
Support Guidelines, a public inquiry line continued to be funded
and information kits on the Child Support Guidelines
and other family law materials continue to be distributed to the public, court
staff, client services associates at FRO and Family Support Workers at the
Ministry of Community and Social Services.
- At the 17 Family Court (“Unified Family Court”) sites, the
Ministry contracts with service providers through a
competitive procurement process to deliver voluntary mediation and parent
information sessions. These services include mediation of most
issues arising due to family breakdown: custody, access, support and division
of property. Off-site mediation services deals with complex issues and there is
a user fee. On-site mediation services are available to deal with narrow issues
for parties on that day's court list, and are free of charge. An Information
and Referral coordinator provides information about mediation services,
community resources and makes appropriate community referrals. The Ministry of
the Attorney General continues to explore the potential of providing mediation
services in child protection cases with specific emphasis on a potential
partnership with the Ministry of Children and Youth Services.
- The MAG has also adopted FRANK, a court case
tracking system, to ensure consistent, province-wide
tracking methodology. The system performs data collection and facilitates the
tracking activities of not only family court cases but also civil and small
claims cases.
- Ontario MAG is using a Web-based index to maintain
a listing of people who have a family court
restraining order against them. The index will leverage the police extranet to
provide police access and will be piloted in 1‑2 court sites to assess
effectiveness. It will be an investigative tool for police to ensure that
family law restraining orders are enforceable and will perform a monitoring and
research analysis function as Court Services Division moves towards
implementation of its long-term information technology strategy. In 2008‑2009, the Index proceeded through various IT“checkpoints” to
ensure that the Index meets with standard government IT practices and security
requirements.The start
date for the pilot of the Index was in the Fall of 2008.
Ministry of Community and Social Services, Family
Responsibility Office (FRO)
- In November 2001, FRO entered into a
partnership with four private sector collection agencies and established the Enhanced
Collection Agencies Project (ECAP), which was concluded in November
2004. A value for dollar audit concluded that ECAP met its mandate by helping
FRO identify difficult to enforce cases so that resources could focus on their
arrears and by assisting FRO in the collection of arrears in these difficult to
enforce cases.
- An enhanced Trace and Locate Unit was formed within
FRO in 2003‑2004 to conduct intensive trace and locate actions on
returned mail. In the past this mail would accumulate and no action would be
taken. This new unit has been extremely successful and has exceeded its targets
by tracing and locating not only current mail being returned but mail that has
been returned in the past.
- In 2003‑2004, FRO launched its new Registration Calls
Unit. This is a dedicated unit that endeavours
to contact approximately 400 new FRO clients per week, within 48 hours of their
case being registered. During this phone call, FRO welcomes them to the program
and explains to them their rights and responsibilities and updates any
incomplete or missing information on the file.
- A new system for referrals to credit bureaus was
developed and implemented by FRO. The system warns the
defaulting payer before they are reported to the credit bureau and gives the
defaulting payer an opportunity to contact FRO to set up a payment schedule in
order to avoid being reported to the credit bureau. If the defaulting payer
does not respond to FRO's warning letter then the payer is reported to the
credit bureau and the system creates an electronic report of defaulting payers
to be reported to the credit bureau. Results from this initiative have been
extremely positive in that payers tend to make contact with FRO to avoid being
reported to the credit bureau.
- As part of the project to enhance reciprocal enforcement with other jurisdictions, FRO's legal counsel worked on
the development of reciprocating agreements with three other jurisdictions: the
Czech Republic, the Slovak Republic and Switzerland. FRO is also currently in
the process of negotiation with Hungary and has reported that those
negotiations are proceeding extremely well.
- FRO has placed considerable emphasis on awareness building
activities and has developed a structured and
strategic outreach initiative that provides more materials to high-traffic
government offices and proceeds with ongoing client and stakeholder outreach
and Web site improvements. FRO has also developed Outreach Sessions for legal professionals, police, judiciary, the bar and family support workers.
- In 2003‑2004, FRO launched the pilot project phase of the PIN
project. FRO has moved to stage two and three
of the PIN project and is now issuing PINs to all newly registered FRO clients
and to clients who phone the Call Centre.
- FRO has also undertaken research activities including the implementation of the national Maintenance Enforcement Survey in Ontario. The Maintenance Enforcement Survey has been in place since
1999‑2000. The purpose of the project is to collect data and deliver
tables for inclusion in a national survey of provincial and territorial child and
spousal support data.
- In 2003‑2004, FRO started preliminary work on a Client
Satisfaction Survey. It is critical for FRO to gain more information
about the clients (payers and recipients) it serves and
about the quality of client service that FRO provides to these clients.
- Ontario FRO is also undertaking a Document Processing Business
Improvement Project that will assist in streamlining the paper work. FRO scans
an average of 50,000 documents each month and this number continues to grow. They
will review the scanning process and look at
implementing auto-scan fax machines which would enable a fast and efficient
delivery of documents directly to the case owners which would reduce the wait
time for documents.
- The fund allowed Ontario FRO to implement and coordinate the
Legal Services Branch Proof of Concept project. The
objective is to assess whether greater efficiency and greater effectiveness can
be realized by increased usage of in-house counsel and reduced reliance on
panel lawyers in default proceedings and other default-related motions. If the project
demonstrates the value of the in-house approach, it will also provide valuable
information to support the request to fund in-house counsel positions wherever
feasible and appropriate in other areas of the province.
- An Administrative Recalculation Service was implemented and that will
provide revision of income information provided annually by the support
payer and recalculates his/her support order by reference to the Child
Support Guidelines without the need for intervention by the courts.
- The services of a consultant are retained to help identify key
performance indicators and assist in the
development of a performance measurement framework.
- In 2008‑2009 FRO undertook a Document Processing Business
Improvement Project that will assist in streamlining
the paper work. FRO scans an average of 50,000 documents each month and this
number continues to grow. They will review the scanning process and look at
implementing auto-scan fax machines which would enable a fast and efficient
delivery of documents directly to the case owners which would reduce the wait
time for documents.
- Also in 2008‑2009, FRO undertook a Case Management Proof of
Concept project as part of the transition to case
management. The transition will assist the clients in remitting payments in a
more timely fashion. It will also allow for true “case management” which will
enable the case workers to focus directly on their case load. Statistical
information will be captured and analyzed at the end of the project to
determine how successful the Proof of Concept unit is in comparison to the
control unit.
Manitoba
- Manitoba's Family Conciliation, Department of Family Services and
Housing Manitoba offers free of charge a parent information program called For
the Sake of the Children, which is delivered as a six-hour program
divided into two seminars. The first seminar is generic
with all participants attending. With assistance from program specialists and
by completing a “self screening questionnaire” participants enrol in one of two
programs provided in the second seminar. One seminar is designed for parents
with lower conflict relationships where higher contact is possible. The other
is designed for parents in higher conflict relationships where lower contact is
preferable. To address remote service delivery and the needs of the northern
communities, Manitoba launched a CD‑ROM package in November 2003
containing information from the first seminar that includes a copy of the Legal
Considerations video followed by the production of the second seminar on CD‑ROM
format. Parents located in northern communities can obtain a copy of the CD‑ROM
package through a number of service providers such as their local library,
women's resource centres, court offices and legal aid offices to name a few. A
portion of Manitoba's funding is used to offset administrative and operational
program costs.
- The Comprehensive Co-Mediation Program became a
service integrated with Family Conciliation, Department of Manitoba Family Services
and Housing, after the Comprehensive Co-Mediation and Mediation Internship
Pilot Project ended in September 2000. The Comprehensive Co-Mediation Program provides parents with a cost-effective alternative to
litigation while helping to reduce the levels of conflict between parents.
Comprehensive Co-Mediation involves a consideration of all the issues that
arise from separation/divorce: parenting issues (parental responsibilities/time
sharing), child support, spousal support and division of marital property. A
family law specialist/lawyer and a family relations specialist/social worker
work together with the family to assist in resolving their issues. After
completing the co-mediation process, a written agreement is drafted, reflecting
those issues that are successfully resolved through co-mediation. This agreement
is then forwarded to the participants' lawyers for review and possibly made
into a legal separation agreement or a consent order. Ninety‑two percent
of the mediated cases reported reaching a full or partial agreement with the
majority of these (73%) being full agreements. The demand for this program has
risen considerably resulting in a waiting list of two to three months on
average.
- For over a decade the Manitoba Court of Queen's Bench Family Division
has been operating a Case Management Program in Winnipeg. The
case management process is intended to promote a
non-contentious resolution of family law matters, reduce unnecessary delays and
minimize costs to litigants. A critical component of case management is the
case conference, an informal meeting between the judge, the parties and their
lawyers. The goal of the case conference is to encourage parties to work
together to reach a satisfactory solution to their cases. Only if the case
cannot be resolved in this non-contentious manner (or if the matter is deemed
urgent) will the judge schedule a contested hearing. During the initial phase
10-20% of new cases were randomly selected for case management, and in November
2002 case management was implemented 100% in Winnipeg. An evaluation was
conducted in 2003‑2004 to measure the level of success in the expanded
program and the effectiveness of the court process and procedures. The Case
Management of Family Matters brochure is available on the internet in English and in French.
- As part of the Family Division Case Management process, the Brief
Consultation Service provides families and their lawyers, as well as
the court, with brief, timely consultation services regarding children's
developmental issues; post-separation parenting; post-separation communication options; counselling needs; information sharing
with children related to separation/divorce; scheduling issues and access
options; and information/screening regarding other relevant services. A brief
focused assessment is conducted by a Family Conciliation counsellor who meets
with the parents and if necessary with the child(ren) and prepares a report for
the court within five weeks of the court referral.
- The Automated Family Court Order Project, or the
“Auto Order” computer process, eliminates traditional delays by enabling family
court orders to be produced immediately after a court
hearing. The Family Law Branch staff creates a Draft Order using the Auto Order
computer system and electronically submits it into the Court Registry System.
In the courtroom the clerk edits from the Draft Order (prepared by counsel) and
electronically submits into the Court Registry System and distributes it to all
parties—all prior to anyone leaving the courtroom. Manitoba's Automated
Family Court Order Project, or the“Auto Order” computer process, is in
its 1st year of release. The new AFCO System
to the Court of Queen's Bench Master's Maintenance Enforcement Court was
implemented at the end of 2007‑2008. In 2008‑2009, the next phase
to take place, involves a release to the remaining general Family Division
courtrooms in Winnipeg and to external legal professionals. The Auto Order
Standard Clauses are available on the Internet in English and in French.
- As of July 2005, Manitoba Justice began operating a Child
Support Recalculation Service. Part of a
two-year pilot project, the service recalculates certain child support orders
at regular intervals, based on updated income information. To be eligible for
recalculation:
- The order must contain an amount for child support based on the
Child Support Guidelines tables.
- The child support order must, in most cases, be based on the
actual income of the parent paying the child support.
- Both parents must live in Manitoba.
- One of the parents must get a court order authorizing the
recalculation.
- Manitoba's A
Guide to Changing a Child Support Order in Manitoba is intended to help
a parent apply to Court in Manitoba to change a child support order. This
comprehensive guide contains information on the requirements and procedures of
the courts for child support variations, a resource section as well as a
glossary of terms to assist a parent in understanding the procedural and legal
terminology used in the variation process. The Guide is available on the
Internet in English and in French.
- First published in 1994, the Family
Law in Manitoba public information booklet has been revised several
times over the past ten years to reflect changes in provincial and federal
legislation. The booklet is designed to provide separating and divorcing
parents with an overview of family law and the legal system and the services
and resources available to assist them. Manitoba revised the version of the 2005 edition in 2007‑2008.
Approximately 2,000 copies of the French booklet is being produced. The Family Law in Manitoba, 2008 booklet is available on the Internet
in English and in French.
- Since Manitoba's new Common-law
Partners' Property and Related Amendments Act came into force on June 30,
2004, common-law partners have been able to register their relationship with
Vital Statistics. New property laws that took effect the same day give
common-law partners (who have lived together for a certain period of time or
registered their relationship with Vital Statistics) the same rights that
married couples have to family property on separation or death of a partner. A
public information pamphlet describing how the Act can affect common-law
partners and a section on frequently asked questions was developed with the
support of the CCFJF.
- A Special Investigation Unit was established in
Winnipeg's Maintenance Enforcement Program in 2002‑2003
to establish consistent, aggressive enforcement practices with default
hearings. Formerly known as the Compliance Unit, MEP consolidated all default
hearings using both levels of court available into a single caseload and
prepared evidence for these processes. As a result, the Unit continues to
secure fuller compliance for some of the most difficult files. This initiative offers a training opportunity
for staff to do a general file review across the program.
Saskatchewan
- The Parent Education Sessions include options for
resolving disputes; the Child Support Guidelines; stages of separation and
divorce; the impact of separation and divorce on
children and parents; and the importance of ongoing positive parenting. To
address parents with high-conflict needs, Saskatchewan has developed a
high-conflict module.
- Also, Saskatchewan piloted the Access Facilitation program where parents in the program first attend a
Parenting after Separation and Divorce information session offered by Family
Justice Services, followed by a legal information session with a lawyer from
the Family Law Information Centre. Parents then participate in up to four joint
mediation sessions to work through access conflict and develop a parenting
plan. The Access Facilitation program links and builds on these existing
services to provide a comprehensive and integrated strategy for resolving
access issues.
- A curriculum and series of videos was developed for children
experiencing separation or divorce. Children learn to understand what
they are experiencing, how to communicate with
their parents and that they are not alone in dealing with these issues.
- The Support Variation Project provides an
out-of-court alternative available to lower-income parents who can agree on
varying their child support order or agreement. As part of its information and
resource component, the Support Variation Project also responds to requests for
assistance with self-help kits for court applications to vary child support.
- Saskatchewan Justice continues to operate the provincial toll-free
information lines, one for the north and another for the southern part
of the province. They are also updating the aging
Interactive Voice Response (IVR) system in order to mitigate the risk of
failure. The new redevelopment of the system includes: establish a remote connection to the existing IVR, gather
information from the existing IVR, develop and test programming to convert
telephone applications, review and convert start-up procedures, convert and
test new data import application, configure, test and convert specific file
applications, prepare the IVR server application installation plan, correct
software bugs, and ensure that custom cabling operates.
- Specialized self-help kits for the use of
self-represented litigants seeking to vary court orders were developed in 2003‑04
by family law lawyers. The kit is available either in
print or on-line. There are now available a variety of kits including: Child or
Spousal Support Variation; Variation for a child over 18; Custody or Access
Variation; Preparing a Separation Agreement; Initial Application for Custody,
Access and/or Child Support; Preparing a Consent Order; Inter-jurisdictional
Support Variation of a Divorce Act Order; and several other services.
- The Maintenance Enforcement Office helps collect
maintenance or support payments ordered by the court or agreed to by two
parties. The MEO enrols, receives and processes
payments as ordered by the courts, enforcing court orders and agreements if
necessary. Saskatchewan is also conducting Maintenance Enforcement and Child
Support Information Sessions in northern and rural communities. The information
sessions covers all aspects of child support and enforcement of child support
orders and agreements.
- This jurisdiction conducted several researches on what family
law services are required by Aboriginal communities and whether
existing family law and related programs and services
meet those needs through consultations and analysis of existing reports from
other jurisdictions. There was also the development of a CD-Rom version of the
parent education program for use in Aboriginal, rural, and remote communities.